Use the worksheet to identify missing answers. It does not score contractors or determine a fair price.

Make sure the proposals describe the same job

Write a one-sentence description of the problem or project. Compare the proposed work against that description, then note differences in materials, quantity, temporary protection, and cleanup.

Where proposals differ, ask the providers to explain why. Avoid assuming a shorter document includes the same details as a longer scope.

Record the details before deciding

Our comparison worksheet keeps three proposals in view. Fill in only what the provider has actually stated. A blank is an unanswered question, not a negative score.

Nothing entered in the worksheet is sent to Roofing Hound or stored on our server. Copy or print your comparison if you want to keep it; refreshing the page clears the fields.

Your estimate comparison

Read each written proposal and mark what it explicitly says. “Not specified” is an unanswered question; “Excluded” identifies a responsibility to resolve. A low total alone does not establish equivalent scope.

Worksheet entries stay in this page's memory and are not submitted or saved by this tool. Print before leaving. Do not enter contact details, addresses or access codes. Normal site analytics may record a page visit.

Written scope, proposal by proposal
CompareProposal 1Proposal 2Proposal 3
Provider or labelNot specifiedNot specifiedNot specified
Quoted totalNot specifiedNot specifiedNot specified
Scope of workNot specifiedNot specifiedNot specified
MaterialsNot specifiedNot specifiedNot specified
Hidden decking workNot specifiedNot specifiedNot specified
Permits and inspectionsNot specifiedNot specifiedNot specified
Temporary protectionNot specifiedNot specifiedNot specified
Cleanup and accessNot specifiedNot specifiedNot specified
TimingNot specifiedNot specifiedNot specified
WarrantyNot specifiedNot specifiedNot specified
Details and exclusionsNot specifiedNot specifiedNot specified

Different stated scope: No differences among the answered items yet. Unanswered items are still unresolved.

Questions for your next conversation

These prompts follow your selections. They do not evaluate credentials, quality, safety or a fair price. Mark “Not applicable” only after confirming that an item does not apply to this project.

Proposal 1

  • Which roof areas and work are included, and what is outside the scope?
  • Which products, quantities and substitutions are specified?
  • How is unexpected decking work documented, priced and approved?
  • Who checks requirements, applies, pays fees and arranges inspections?
  • Who protects exposed areas during a pause, and is it included?
  • What cleanup, debris removal and household access are included?
  • What are the expected dates and the plan if weather delays the work?
  • Which written warranties cover materials and workmanship, and what is excluded?

Proposal 2

  • Which roof areas and work are included, and what is outside the scope?
  • Which products, quantities and substitutions are specified?
  • How is unexpected decking work documented, priced and approved?
  • Who checks requirements, applies, pays fees and arranges inspections?
  • Who protects exposed areas during a pause, and is it included?
  • What cleanup, debris removal and household access are included?
  • What are the expected dates and the plan if weather delays the work?
  • Which written warranties cover materials and workmanship, and what is excluded?

Proposal 3

  • Which roof areas and work are included, and what is outside the scope?
  • Which products, quantities and substitutions are specified?
  • How is unexpected decking work documented, priced and approved?
  • Who checks requirements, applies, pays fees and arranges inspections?
  • Who protects exposed areas during a pause, and is it included?
  • What cleanup, debris removal and household access are included?
  • What are the expected dates and the plan if weather delays the work?
  • Which written warranties cover materials and workmanship, and what is excluded?

Ask a specific follow-up question

Instead of asking why one provider costs more, ask about a particular scope difference: whether a material is included, what happens if an assumption changes, or which warranty covers the work.

The FTC recommends multiple written estimates and an explanation for major differences. Use that conversation to make the decision clearer, not to force every provider into an identical quote.

Sources and review

Question frameworks and project-organization suggestions are Roofing Hound’s editorial recommendations. Source links do not imply endorsement. See our editorial approach.

Prepare for the next call

Compare written proposals and prepare follow-up questions.

Build and print a provider-call checklist, or compare local providers.

We can review your project and look for an independent provider. This free service is manual; availability and response time are not guaranteed.

Request free help ↗